Spudbilt Logo critique

[noant]

I need some feedback. This is for a guy who makes off road products for dirtbikes, motocross type stuff. He currently had the spud character that you will see on the top left option. I changed him up a little bit just to see if it may help but not sure.

They are still in a rough stage, but i'd like to know a direction you all think would be the best route to completion.

Thanks.

[defragmybrain]

the second one in column one is creative, with the handling of the "T". maybe bring the spud character a bit closer to the text with the T, so that it looks more cohesive. i likes it.

[Arkady]

The character needs to be better drawn. Row2 Column1 is definitely the best concept.

[defragmybrain]

i agree. new spud image.

[StiligeCecilie]

Yeah, if you shrink the logo, you won't be able to recognize the character.

[noant]

The client wants the character he has given me. I'm in the process of trying to re draw the character and present him with the fresh version.

Thanks all!