Please Review These Ideas

[bryceray]

I'm trying to work on a layout. I've got 3 different ideas (only difference is banner). If they all suck that is fine but please explain your opinion. Tell me what you like and what you dont like. Thanks!

www.principlewebdesign.com/tuba/layout.jpg
www.principlewebdesign.com/tuba/layout2.jpg
www.principlewebdesign.com/tuba/layout3.jpg

[Carla-Jay]

I like the 2nd over the others the strict block layout works a bit better

[skyrocket]

no 1 & no 3 look the same to me(?). I like no 2 because it doesn't have that curved header and also the opaque section for the title. it's still a bit blocky and needs more work... :)

[ianm]

1 and 3 ARE exactly the same - they all are except for the header part on 2, there is no layout ideas to review, the layout is exactly the same on all three jpgs

[bryceray]

Lol sorry,
I didn't relize when i uploaded that somehow the third image overwrote he first.

[El Peligroso]

Originally Posted by ianm

1 and 3 ARE exactly the same - they all are except for the header part on 2, there is no layout ideas to review, the layout is exactly the same on all three jpgs

If you look at the first post it tells you that!!!

[dannynosleeves]

Id say number 2

[prewe]

#2 here as well, i'd skip the scanlines somewhere. dunno where though.

[bryceray]

Alright,
What do you think of #2 compared to this:
http://www.principlewebdesign.com/tuba/layout4.jpg

I did it real quick so there are a few small errors in the graphic but i think u will get the idea.

[bryceray]

I've changed a few things around and added an mp3 player and some text. Please leave some feedback, i would appreciate it. Thanks!